Washingtonpost.com: Cosmic Markdown: EPA Says Life Is Worth Less
By David A. Fahrenthold
Washington Post Staff Writer
Someplace else, people might tell you that human life is priceless. In Washington, the federal government has appraised it like a '96 Camaro with bad brakes.
Last week, it was revealed that an Environmental Protection Agency office had lowered its official estimate of life's value, from about $8.04 million to about $7.22 million. That decision has put a spotlight on the concept of the "Value of a Statistical Life," in which the Washington bureaucracy takes on a question usually left to preachers and poets.
This value is routinely calculated by several agencies, each putting its own dollar figure on the worth of life -- not any particular person's life, just that of a generic American. The figure is then used to judge whether potentially lifesaving policy measures are really worth the cost.
A human life, based on an economic analysis grounded in observations of everyday Americans, typically turns out to be worth $5 million to $8 million -- about as much as a mega-mansion or a middle infielder.
Now, for the first time, the EPA has used this little-known process to devalue life, something that environmentalists say could set a scary precedent, making it seem that lifesaving pollution reductions are not worth the cost.
"By reducing the value of human life, which is really a devious way of cooking the books, the perceived benefits of cleaning up the air seem less," said Frank O'Donnell of the District-based group Clean Air Watch. "That has the effect of weakening the case for pollution cleanup."
To grasp the mind-bending concept of a Blue Book value on life, government officials say it is important to remember that they are not thinking about anyone specifi c. That happens in lawsuits, when plaintiffs seek to be compensated for a life lost -- and there, it can involve personal factors such as the deceased's lost income.
Here, officials say, they are trying instead to come up with the value of a typical life, without any personal information attached.
They might know, for instance, that a new cut in air pollution will save 50 lives a year -- though they don't know who those people might be. Still they want to decide whether saving them is worth the cost, officials say, and it helps to assign a dollar value to each life saved.
Read the rest of the article:
The OFFICIAL Dilbert Widget
Blog Archive
-
▼
2008
(435)
-
▼
July
(20)
- CNN: 'Last Lecture' professor dies at 47
- Zen Habits: Now Do This, and The Single-Tasking Ph...
- Washingtonpost.com: Cosmic Markdown: EPA Says Life...
- Pakistan Daily Times: Scarecrow Amy alarms the birds
- Live Science: Human Speech Traced to Talking Fish
- NPR: Geriatric Care for Animals
- AP: Judge says Girl's name, Talula Does The Hula, ...
- Pakistan Daily Times: Poodle Driven Car
- Enlightened Living: Empathy Deficit Disorder? Seri...
- Chigago Tribune: Not all cute and cuddly in land o...
- Telegraph.co.uk: Don't set dogs on criminals with ...
- MyFox Twin Cities: Minnesota Web Developer Puts Fa...
- A Rare Breed of Love - Official Site of the Book
- Bloomberg.com:Porno, Beer, Bible Share MIT Economi...
- The Onion: 'No Values Voters' Looking To Support M...
- Milwaukee Journal Sentinel: Wis. Humane Society to...
- Goodnight Sweetheart: Try this at home!
- Educator Humor: Aphorisms for the 21st Century, by...
- NYT: An Ideal Husband
- Educator Humor: Ruminations
-
▼
July
(20)
- dogs
- rescue
- pets
- NYT
- humor
- snicker
- books
- poodles
- reading
- NPR
- animals
- UTube
- horse racing
- poetry
- puppy mills
- video
- Mutts
- cruelty
- mcsweeneys
- Garrison Keillor
- abuse
- discovery channel
- horses
- philosophy
- vick
- candidates
- cars
- cats
- depression
- discovery news
- eight belles
- minnesota vikings
- photos
- television
- wikihow
- writer's almanac
- National Geographic
- Robert Frost
- The Old Scout
- Unitarians
- baby
- best friends
- coffee
- cute
- domestic abuse
- english
- grammar
- jesse bering
- kenechi udeze
- memory
- morality
- obesity
- pit bulls
- politics
- quirky little things
- rent
- sydney morning herald
- the onion
- women
- AFV
- Conditions and Diseases
- Dog
- John Grat
- Michael Smerconish
- Minnesota
- PETA
- Pain Management
- Poodle
- Rescues and Shelters
- Toy Poodle
- Valentine's Day
- Virtual reality
- accident
- aging
- anger
- animal rights activists
- animal testing
- animal welfare groups
- ayn rand
- ball state university
- barbaro
- bats
- best friend
- bird
- birds
- blogger
- blogs
- bulwer lytton
- campaign
- camping
- cancer
- canine horizons
- cartoon
- cat people
- cell phones
- child
- clock
- clowns
- communication
- companionship
- deer
- digital
- dip
- dog fighting
- dog people
- duluth news tribune
- editing
- edmonton sun
- election
- elephants
- employees
- employers
- euthanasia
- exploitation
- extinct
- fiction contest
- football
- friends
- gadgets
- games
- gastric bypass
- global warming
- grooming
- huh?
- humane nation
- ikramuddin
- insurance
- intelligence
- iris dement
- jay leeming
- jim nayder
- lancaster online
- laura erickson
- library
- literature
- loneliness
- lost
- michael vick
- miss bea
- morning
- nbc news
- npr music
- old age
- pandas
- people
- petfinder
- philadelphia enquirer
- photo contests
- photography
- photoshop
- picket fence poodle rescue
- pogue's posts
- polar bear
- ponydoodles
- protection
- puppies
- radio
- relationships
- romance
- romantic
- rosalie
- safety
- save
- seattle post-intelligencer
- seinfeld
- slate.com
- sleep
- soldier
- soul
- speaking
- spelling
- sport
- squirrels
- steampunk
- stephen king
- surgery
- technology
- think
- transplants
- trauma
- veterinarians
- virtual pets
- voting
- warnings
- wayne pacelle
- weight loss
- wind turbines
- work
0 comments:
Post a Comment